Balancing Author Voice with Rulebook Rigor

Behind the Die by Charlie Stayton

One of the biggest challenges in tabletop role-playing game design—whether you’re writing a full adventure module, a homebrew supplement, or even just house rules for your group—is finding the balance between your unique authorial voice and the rigor required of rulebook writing.

Too much voice, and the rules can feel muddled. Too much rigor, and the text risks reading like a technical manual. The real craft lies in walking the line.

Why Voice Matters

Your authorial voice is what makes your work yours. It’s the color in your narration, the sly humor in your NPC descriptions, the evocative way you set the scene. Voice helps players and GMs feel immersed before the dice ever hit the table. It’s also what makes your material memorable—no one recalls the stat block, but they’ll remember that you described a villain as “smiling like a shark at a feast.”

A strong voice also reassures your readers that you know where they are emotionally in the game: when it’s time to laugh, when it’s time to be tense, and when it’s time to lean in.

Why Rigor Matters

But rules demand clarity. If a GM can’t parse an encounter mechanic quickly at the table, your dramatic tension is lost. Rulebook rigor means:

• Consistency (a mechanic written one way here should appear the same elsewhere).

• Precision (using standardized terminology like “bonus action” vs. “free action”).

• Accessibility (structure and formatting that makes it easy to skim).

This rigor ensures that when the dice roll, the outcome is fair, fast, and easy to adjudicate.

Strategies for Balance

So how do you weave both together? A few techniques:

• Layer Your Writing: Put the flavorful description first (“The door groans open, dust motes swirling like startled spirits…”) and the mechanical effect second (“The door is locked, DC 15 Strength check to break”). Readers get the tone and the tool.

• Use Consistent Sidebars or Boxes: Voice in the main text, rigor in the call-out. For instance, narrate the ominous ruins in prose, then box out the encounter stats for quick reference.

• Adopt a Style Guide: Even for personal projects, build a checklist. Decide when you’ll bold terms, how you’ll present DCs, and how stat blocks will be formatted. That consistency allows your voice to shine without tripping over technicalities.

• Read Aloud Test: Pretend you’re running it live. Read your description of a scene, then immediately try to apply the rules text. If you stumble, reformat. If you smile, keep it.

The Payoff

When you nail this balance, your work becomes more than a manual—it becomes a playable story. GMs can trust the mechanics and still enjoy your personality on the page. Players feel your fingerprints without ever losing track of the rules.

It’s not just about writing a module that works—it’s about creating one that sings.

---

Closing Thought:
Think of yourself as both novelist and engineer. The novelist enchants; the engineer ensures the bridge won’t collapse. In tabletop design, you need both.