The Economy of Magic: Pricing the Priceless in Your World

By Charlie Stayton, Behind the Die

At some point in every campaign, a player will ask the dreaded question:
“How much does this magic item cost?”

And if your internal response is a mix of “It depends” and “Please don’t break my economy,” you’re not alone.

Magic doesn’t just bend the laws of physics—it warps the foundations of trade, power, and even mortality. And yet, we often rely on loose tables and vague assumptions to handle its cost. In this post, we’ll explore how to build a believable magical economy that goes beyond gold pieces and dives into scarcity, consequence, and cultural value.

The False Simplicity of GP

Dungeons & Dragons (and most fantasy RPGs) use gold as a universal currency. It’s a helpful abstraction, but it flattens a complex truth: not all value is market value. Just because a Potion of Invisibility is worth “2,500 gp” in the DMG doesn’t mean it should be available in every market.

Ask yourself:

• Would a village that fears unseen spirits sell invisibility potions—or destroy them?

• Would an elven artisan trade a generational heirloom for coin, or only for a favor owed to their house?

• Can a magic sword even be bought, or does it bind itself to a destined wielder?

You’re not just pricing an item. You’re assigning cultural weight to a miracle.

Scarcity, Access, and Control

Magic in your world should feel precious, regulated, or dangerous—depending on your setting’s tone.

• Scarcity: Maybe only one known enchanter in the region can create permanent magic. What do they charge? Who do they refuse?

• Access: Are magic shops public marketplaces—or private brokers serving nobles, churches, and guilds? Consider the social cost of magic.

• Control: Does the government or a mage college outlaw certain magic items? Is there a magical “arms trade”?

A +1 sword doesn’t just cost money. It might cost trust, reputation, or a risky favor.

Alternative Currencies: Beyond Coin

Gold is just one way to pay. For magic, consider crafting a broader economy that reflects the power being exchanged.

1. Reagents & Rare Components

• A potion might require moonlotus gathered under a lunar eclipse.

• Scroll ink might be brewed from kraken blood and voidsalt.

• These components can’t just be bought—they must be found or bartered.

2. Favors, Secrets, and Memories

• “Bring me a secret the world doesn’t know.”

• “Tell me the name your mother never spoke aloud.”

• These intangible currencies make magical transactions story-rich and emotionally charged.

3. Time & Risk

• Want that ring of spell storing? Great—guard the enchanter’s caravan for a month.

• Want to be resurrected? Fine—but the soul must want to return, and the priest won’t try twice.

The Marketplace of Miracles

Magic shops can exist—but they should feel like walking into a vault of forbidden wonders or a black-market bazaar, not a medieval Target.

Ideas for Magical Marketplaces:

• The Arcane Exchange: A hidden auction where wizards bid with power and prophecy.

• The Ember Vault: A dwarven relic hall where one item can be claimed—if your request is judged worthy.

• The Wyrm’s Tooth: A floating merchant ship crewed by retired adventurers who sell stories and steel.

Each location should feel like a quest, not a catalog.

Pricing Tips for DMs

If you do need to set prices, here’s a flexible approach that maintains mystery:

• Common Items (potions, scrolls): Use gold, but require availability checks, wait times, or minor favors.

• Uncommon to Rare Items: Base price in GP + 1 story cost (quest, service, rare ingredient).

• Very Rare to Legendary: Only available through story. No price tag. Ever.

Magic, after all, is not mundane. Treating it like a sword or shield robs it of wonder.

Final Thought: Price is a Story Hook

When a player asks “How much does it cost?” answer with a story.

“The enchanter looks you over, eyes cloudy with age. ‘For coin? No. But if you can bring me the tear of a ghost who remembers their name, we have a deal.’”

That’s not a price tag. That’s a plot.

And in a world of magic, that’s the economy that really matters.

---

Do you use gold, favors, or something stranger to price magic in your world? Share your magical market ideas in the comments below.